![]() |
|
Uh-Oh, here comes a God vs Science thread |
Mark Oates
Member #1,146
March 2001
![]() |
{"name":"325px-Lcb_book.jpg","src":"\/\/djungxnpq2nug.cloudfront.net\/image\/cache\/7\/9\/79a93377da2b2e2ae2c839f666f0ce94.jpg","w":325,"h":325,"tn":"\/\/djungxnpq2nug.cloudfront.net\/image\/cache\/7\/9\/79a93377da2b2e2ae2c839f666f0ce94"} Oh hai! In teh beginnin Ceiling Cat maded the skys an teh Urfs, but he no eated dem. -- |
gnolam
Member #2,030
March 2002
![]() |
_Kronk_ said: Second: even if all of the energy in the universe was compressed to a hot little .zip file, even that energy had to come from somewhere. So it still doesn't explain anything Alas, assuming a god doesn't solve anything. Now you've just introduced one more problem - explaining how he (she/it/specify as appropriate) came into existence. -- |
bamccaig
Member #7,536
July 2006
![]() |
_Kronk_ said: But then Adam and Eve messed it up, etc, you know that story.
Seems rather silly that God would punish the universe for a couple of humans making a mistake... What an asshole. _Kronk_ said:
Second: even if all of the energy in the universe was compressed to a hot little .zip file, even that energy had to come from somewhere. So it still doesn't explain anything
OK, Over-Exaggeration-Man, calm down. See also gnolam's post above. _Kronk_ said: Third: the "good part" comes when we have communion with God and know Him on a personal basis, not only after death. The after death part is just even better becuase we are seperated from the consequences of the Fall, e.g., disease, sin, death, suffering, anything not good.
What does it even mean to know God on a personal basis? Think about that for a second. What good is that? I picture sitting down having a beer with him, talking, joking, etc. That's stupid. For starters, you presumably have no body any more, so you're what? A floating cloud of consciousness? To me it sounds more like the promise is that you'll finally get to understand the universe. The ironic thing is that instead of learning about it with the scientists and supporters of the scientific method, you instead opt to refuse that knowledge and hope to learn it all after you die. _Kronk_ said:
I'm sorry if this seems overly spiritual or "religious", but if God created it all, then it naturally all goes back to Him
I'm sorry if I sound overly condescending, but your beliefs (which in the general sense I once held myself) seem completely ridiculous to me. I understand though. When you believe these things it's so easy to believe that you're right (especially with social engineers drilling it into your head in churches, with the tone of their voice, and the words that they say), and so scary to consider being wrong (after all, the people who are wrong "are tortured for all eternity in a fiery prison"; plus most of your peers are probably religious and would exile you for questioning their beliefs). @Mark Oates: OMFG, that's awesome. -- acc.js | al4anim - Allegro 4 Animation library | Allegro 5 VS/NuGet Guide | Allegro.cc Mockup | Allegro.cc <code> Tag | Allegro 4 Timer Example (w/ Semaphores) | Allegro 5 "Winpkg" (MSVC readme) | Bambot | Blog | C++ STL Container Flowchart | Castopulence Software | Check Return Values | Derail? | Is This A Discussion? Flow Chart | Filesystem Hierarchy Standard | Clean Code Talks - Global State and Singletons | How To Use Header Files | GNU/Linux (Debian, Fedora, Gentoo) | rot (rot13, rot47, rotN) | Streaming |
Derezo
Member #1,666
April 2001
![]() |
I'm still caught on why it's so important to choose whether you believe in a God or believe that there is no God. The definition of such a thing isn't very clear, and the outcome of experience seems more related to your actions than to whatever superficial beliefs you may have formed about the nature of reality. Beliefs are something that change throughout time. 5,000 years ago, nobody believed in what you believe in today. 5,000 years from now the result will be the same. People living 5,000 years from now won't be living in "The Year 7011", either. That's just stupid. In fact, I doubt the people of 2100 will refer to it as such. Beliefs are a useful tool of thought, but they are impermanent. They allow you to achieve your goals and aspire to new heights, because you believe that it can be done. I believe that I can accomplish X new task I've never done before, based on my ability to have accomplished tasks T, U and V without struggle. I don't know this, but I can confirm my belief through action. Revelations have occurred all throughout history which have reshaped all previous beliefs, and revelations in your experience can reshape beliefs about what you can or cannot do. Some people believe they can fly, and the revelation that they cannot is sometimes only experienced by everyone else. Is this an Omnipresent God? Doesn't that mean it is me and I am it? Makes the whole concept a little insignificant, don't you think? Sound like a description of reality in action, but that doesn't require any sort of belief to occur. Is this a physical creature of some sort, like a flying spaghetti monster that is in a fixed position? I think that holding a belief in the existence of an undefined entity is a poorly constructed idea. If you're struggling in life, believing in a higher power that can pick you up and set you on the right course can be incredible. However, it is you that sets your course, not some Man in the Sky. I have a number of friends, whose intellect and accomplishments in life I value, that consider the whole God dilemma to be a genetic trait, along with homosexuality, an affinity for mathematics, eye colour, and skin color. In fact, I believe that genetics describe the origins of all life found in nature. However, I'm also sure there's more to it than that. This belief will be revealed to be true or false in my lifetime as the progress of genetic research continues. Imagination is an incredible tool. Use it wisely. "He who controls the stuffing controls the Universe" |
Vanneto
Member #8,643
May 2007
|
_Kronk_ said: Well, if you just disappear when you die, why not die now? What you live for now is irrelevant. This is what you think. If you disappear when you die, it makes it even more pleasant to be alive. To enjoy life. Life is a party, once you're dead, you leave the party. You have to enjoy the party as much as you can, because once you leave, there ain't no coming back. But this is just a matter of different views. You need God to give you a reason to live, others don't. gnolam said: Alas, assuming a god doesn't solve anything. Now you've just introduced one more problem - explaining how he (she/it/specify as appropriate) came into existence.
In the realms of the gaming universe, this statement would be considered a headshot. A "masterkill" if you will. In capitalist America bank robs you. |
Thomas Fjellstrom
Member #476
June 2000
![]() |
_Kronk_ said: Well, if you just disappear when you die, why not die now? Because. I don't want to. -- |
Derezo
Member #1,666
April 2001
![]() |
My biggest trouble at trying to wrap my head around god was trying to get someone to describe God to me. Religion is easy. A set of customs and traditions, rituals and shared beliefs, often filled with anecdotes describing practical philosophies, typically controlled by a central authority. "He who controls the stuffing controls the Universe" |
Neil Roy
Member #2,229
April 2002
![]() |
This is what I believe... I believe you all love to argue. 5 pages in here already?!
--- |
Thomas Fjellstrom
Member #476
June 2000
![]() |
Neil Roy said: 5 pages in here already?! Nope. Only two. Quote: I believe you all love to argue That I can't not agree with. -- |
bamccaig
Member #7,536
July 2006
![]() |
Neil Roy said:
I believe you all love to argue. 5 pages in here already?!
It's only 2. -- acc.js | al4anim - Allegro 4 Animation library | Allegro 5 VS/NuGet Guide | Allegro.cc Mockup | Allegro.cc <code> Tag | Allegro 4 Timer Example (w/ Semaphores) | Allegro 5 "Winpkg" (MSVC readme) | Bambot | Blog | C++ STL Container Flowchart | Castopulence Software | Check Return Values | Derail? | Is This A Discussion? Flow Chart | Filesystem Hierarchy Standard | Clean Code Talks - Global State and Singletons | How To Use Header Files | GNU/Linux (Debian, Fedora, Gentoo) | rot (rot13, rot47, rotN) | Streaming |
type568
Member #8,381
March 2007
![]() |
bamccaig said: Unlike religion, which assumes that the text that passed through the hands of billions of humans over the course of thousands of years is the unquestionable truth No, it's not the case. Religion evolves dramatically, and although the written is "unquestionable truth", interpretations vary accordingly to the situation. The interpretation is also pretty much dependent on the interpretor of course, while the language of science is a lot more strict and not allowing multiple interpretations. I like the comparison of a bible with a dictionary: you can describe anything using the words in the dictionary, with bible the things aren't as flexible but nevertheless.. Arthur Kalliokoski said: That's how you define temperature in matter now that molecules and matter exist. Okay, but when the stuff didn't exist there was no heat.
|
Vanneto
Member #8,643
May 2007
|
Hah, made me laugh Neil!
You can change the number of posts on a page in your settings. This thread is only 2 pages for me.
In capitalist America bank robs you. |
type568
Member #8,381
March 2007
![]() |
4 4me
|
Arthur Kalliokoski
Second in Command
February 2005
![]() |
type568 said: Okay, but when the stuff didn't exist there was no heat. There wasn't time, either, so what cost "it took forever"? They all watch too much MSNBC... they get ideas. |
Thomas Fjellstrom
Member #476
June 2000
![]() |
type568 said: No, it's not the case. Religion evolves dramatically, and although the written is "unquestionable truth", interpretations vary accordingly to the situation. No, because according to our resident expert, the bible is the bible and is absolute. And given that, any "interpretation" is incorrect and likely heresy. Since the bible doesn't change, the religion around it can't either. -- |
type568
Member #8,381
March 2007
![]() |
Arthur Kalliokoski said: There wasn't time, either, so what cost "it took forever"? I didn't ask the question. But the theory is rather nonsense anyways, it's out there just cos' nothing better is invented. But when I attempt to "get in to the infinity of start of all of it", I feel like I'm lost. I'm having that same feeling when I think about since I first did, while I was like.. "Less than a teen"-years-old.
|
Neil Roy
Member #2,229
April 2002
![]() |
Edit: debate ended, at least for me. --- |
bamccaig
Member #7,536
July 2006
![]() |
type568 said: No, it's not the case. Religion evolves dramatically, and although the written is "unquestionable truth", interpretations vary accordingly to the situation.
Certainly. However, the interpretation that is fed to you (by your church leaders, for example), are not to be questioned. Go ahead and question them during a Bible study and see how the room treats you. In high school I went to a Christian "youth group" because of a girl. It was basically a Bible study followed by a "fun night" with games and activities and such. I questioned everything though. Years later a friend from the group (and my childhood) did manage to free her mind for a while, but eventually pressure from her very religious family pulled her back into the net. -- acc.js | al4anim - Allegro 4 Animation library | Allegro 5 VS/NuGet Guide | Allegro.cc Mockup | Allegro.cc <code> Tag | Allegro 4 Timer Example (w/ Semaphores) | Allegro 5 "Winpkg" (MSVC readme) | Bambot | Blog | C++ STL Container Flowchart | Castopulence Software | Check Return Values | Derail? | Is This A Discussion? Flow Chart | Filesystem Hierarchy Standard | Clean Code Talks - Global State and Singletons | How To Use Header Files | GNU/Linux (Debian, Fedora, Gentoo) | rot (rot13, rot47, rotN) | Streaming |
blargmob
Member #8,356
February 2007
![]() |
_Kronk_ said: even if all of the energy in the universe was compressed to a hot little .zip file, even that energy had to come from somewhere. So it still doesn't explain anything Your ignorance and complete misunderstanding of the Big Bang doesn't mean it "doesn't explain anything". Stop being so caught up in your shell, and go do some real research to better understand what it is you are talking about instead of trying to disprove and demote something that you truly know nothing about. --- |
Arthur Kalliokoski
Second in Command
February 2005
![]() |
Neil Roy said: What settings do you use to get only 2? {"name":"VaMqQ.png","src":"\/\/djungxnpq2nug.cloudfront.net\/image\/cache\/9\/b\/9b38e1c4817cdb006240758bcc08f694.png","w":1024,"h":768,"tn":"\/\/djungxnpq2nug.cloudfront.net\/image\/cache\/9\/b\/9b38e1c4817cdb006240758bcc08f694"} They all watch too much MSNBC... they get ideas. |
23yrold3yrold
Member #1,134
March 2001
![]() |
bamccaig said: Certainly. However, the interpretation that is fed to you (by your church leaders, for example, are not to be questioned). Go ahead and question them during a Bible study and see how the room treats you.
Me, in the married men thread said: If someone wants to know something easily verifiable, they should go verify it and stop asking for opinions. Even my old pastor in Winnipeg told us several times from the pulpit not to believe what he said unless we went and verified it for ourselves.
Dunno where this stigma about not questioning religion comes from in the non-religious community. I guess it's natural to assume there's no way anyone could possibly question what they believe as much as you or they'd naturally just come to the same answer you consider obviously correct, huh? Room treats me just fine, thanks old chap. Sorry your isolated personal experience continues to suck an egg. Thomas Fjellstrom said: No, because according to our resident expert, the bible is the bible and is absolute. All religion is based on the same historical texts, amirite? -- |
Neil Roy
Member #2,229
April 2002
![]() |
_Kronk_ said: even if all of the energy in the universe was compressed to a hot little .zip file Hey, we should start our own religion... we'll call it C++ In the beginning there was a highly compressed, hot little zip file, and yay it was hotteth and highly compressed. And C said "Let there be a universe" and he unzipped the file... and he saw that it was good.... and he said, let there be solar system class, and it was so, and he saw it was good... and he said, let us divide the class into public and private members, and he did, and it was good... ...I'm going to hell for that by the way. --- |
bamccaig
Member #7,536
July 2006
![]() |
23yrold3yrold said:
Dunno where this stigma about not questioning religion comes from in the non-religious community. I guess it's natural to assume there's no way anyone could possibly question what they believe as much as you or they'd naturally just come to the same answer you consider obviously correct, huh? You seem quick to jump to conclusions. I grew up "Christian", went to church every week, had a religious family, religious friends, etc. I'm not an outsider to religion at all. Of course, since every fucking church has their own interpretations and ideas you can easily argue that your church is different from mine, and from the ones I've visited, and from the radio and TV programs I've heard/watched. Sure, yours is completely different from every other Christian experience I've seen. Absolutely. As you were then. 23yrold3yrold said: Room treats me just fine, thanks old chap. Sorry your isolated personal experience continues to suck an egg. What did you question of the room? Neil Roy said: ...I'm going to hell for that by the way.
-- acc.js | al4anim - Allegro 4 Animation library | Allegro 5 VS/NuGet Guide | Allegro.cc Mockup | Allegro.cc <code> Tag | Allegro 4 Timer Example (w/ Semaphores) | Allegro 5 "Winpkg" (MSVC readme) | Bambot | Blog | C++ STL Container Flowchart | Castopulence Software | Check Return Values | Derail? | Is This A Discussion? Flow Chart | Filesystem Hierarchy Standard | Clean Code Talks - Global State and Singletons | How To Use Header Files | GNU/Linux (Debian, Fedora, Gentoo) | rot (rot13, rot47, rotN) | Streaming |
type568
Member #8,381
March 2007
![]() |
bamccaig said: Certainly. However, the interpretation that is fed to you (by your church leaders, for example), are not to be questioned. Go ahead and question them during a Bible study and see how the room treats you. I absolutely respect any religion with which I'm at least somewhat familiar, and out of what I understand: their respective philosophies define appropriate behaviour(yes, including Muslims, they're just yet interpreting it wrong. Oh well, Christians weren't much better a while ago). However, what I see in the countries I'm related to(Israel, Russia): The "Rabanut Israel" is greedy selfish shit(with all my respect to the Holy Tannah itself), and the same about Russian church: the conservative nonsense is just irrelevant for todays world. From time to time greed is also being involved making things even worse. I'm very much "on the surface" of the topic, but it's rather.. "dirty"
|
23yrold3yrold
Member #1,134
March 2001
![]() |
bamccaig said: You seem quick to jump to conclusions. I grew up "Christian", went to church every week, had a religious family, religious friends, etc. I'm not an outsider to religion at all. Nothing I said implied you were. Your post I was replying to, however, assumed a) people accept the interpretation given without question, b) an interpretation is necessary at all (personally, I didn't go to church for years and just did my own research), c) questions would automatically have a negative effect like they're new or something, etc, etc. Quote: So what kinds of things have you questioned of the room?
Dude, I play nothing but Devil's Advocate around here. What kind of questions wouldn't I ask if I did Bible studies? Can you even imagine? -- |
|
|